Christmas is only days away! While D.W. adds to the list of presents she wants, Arthur sets out to find the perfect gift to give Santa and nothing seems good enough. Arthur and his friends visit Santa at the toy store but Santa won't tell Arthur what he wants. Then, Arthur sees Santa at the ice cream shop, and at the Chinese food restaurant, and the Deli and on TV eating pickled peppers. Arthur has an idea. With a little help from his little sister, he cooks Santa a feast, and Christmas is a success!